Wednesday, 1 August 2018

Stand by Meesha, or else shave your meesha

This week I got a whatsapp forward. The local unit of the Nair Service Society (NSS), a body that represents Nairs, an upper caste in Kerala, calling upon all community members to boycott Mathrubhumi newspaper till it apologises for publishing S. Hareesh’s novel Meesha (Moustache).

Then I got another forward, this one called the NSS resolution an interference in personal space and attack on individual rights. This message also warned that a boycott of Mathrubhumi will invariably help Malayala Manorama, owned by a Christian. But it didn’t question the assault on free speech.

Here is the excerpt from the novel which they are objecting to:

Why do girls take bath and go to temples all decked-up? A friend who used to accompany my walks till six months ago asked me once. 

"To pray," I said. 

"No, give a closer look. Why put on your best and doll up to pray? They are sub-consciously conveying their readiness for sex." 

I laughed. 

"If not why do they fail to turn up at temples four or five days a month? To let others know they are not ready, especially the temple priests. You know, they were the real playboys those days."

It’s obvious the chivalrous Nair men, or the Sangh Parivar elements they are backing, can’t have any of it. But we are yet to hear from any women about this, all the whatsapp messages circulating are valiant men pledging to save their sundar-susheel sisters.

Even these moral cops would admit that long before we got shopping malls, temples were where we wooed our girls. Where we schemed chance meetings to get the sandalwood tika on our foreheads by them. Many a love affair has taken root and blossomed in temples or ulsavapparambu.

Now, take the ban on women visiting temples during menstruation: it is not enforced the way it is in Kerala anywhere else in India. The character in the novel in his own way is giving a reasoning for a subject which is now being debated by no less than the Supreme Court.

If art, literature and films were to follow the Hindutva cowboys’ newly drafted moral code, we would have villains in films seeking the permission of women before a rape scene, drunkards reading out the ‘alcohol is injurious to health’ warnings before every sip of brandy and ‘shwaasakosam’ warning before every puff.

DC Books’ decision to publish Meesha is laudable. Such nonsense should be called out right from the beginning, and any attempt to censor must be nipped in the bud. If we don’t do it, we might as well shave our moustache and pretend it never was there. 

Thursday, 12 July 2018

Things Modric does, Messi & Ronaldo can't

Luka Modric is the V.V.S. Laxman of football. For many reasons.

I don’t think anybody worships Modric like they do Messi or Ronaldo. People will come to blows debating which of Messi and Ronaldo is the greatest. But I don’t think anybody will pick a fight for Modric.

Modric is a Test player. Croatia is the first nation to enter the final after three back to back extra time matches. Modric was in all three, and was on the pitch almost for the whole duration. Never did he show any sign of fatigue. But then he lived and survived a civil war, this is only a football tournament.

Modric is no Messi or Ronaldo. For instance Messi and Ronaldo can’t lift the morale, spirit and game of his national teammates like Modric does. Often when Argentina or Portugal lose, the blame is reserved for their ‘substandard’ teammates. Not Modric. He will toil with them, he will run with them till the final whistle is blown. Modric revels in playing with the tailenders, so to say.

On Wednesday, none of the two goals were results of a Modric assist, yet he left his signature on the match. He stayed back when needed, he pushed ahead when needed, he passed and passed and passed, Modric is a selfless team man.

And what is more, Modric does all this with that lanky frame of his. Among the sprinters of football, he is the marathon runner. Place him under the microscope, chances are you won’t find any muscle, just flesh and blood. If you didn’t know Modric plays football, you won’t believe he plays football. Modric looks like any of us, very ordinary, but extraordinarily gifted.

After watching him, I am inspired to play football. No Messi, no Ronaldo can ever do that.

Friday, 8 June 2018

If Hedgewar was a great son of Mother India, who was Gandhi?

Last week I was having beer with a few friends. At some point we decided to go to Haridwar. I was bored of drinking at home, wanted to drink in a new setting. Of course I wanted to take a dip in Ganga to absolve myself of all sins that I had committed till then, so that I could start committing new sins.

The point is there was a purpose to that trip. We do things purposefully, even if we don’t acknowledge it. Now what inspired former president Pranab Mukherjee to fly down to Nagpur and attend the RSS convocation ceremony?

There could be many reasons.

Mukherjee says dialogue is the essence of democracy. One should keep the dialogue on. So he wants to have a dialogue with an organisation which couldn’t tolerate a nuanced homage to Muhammed Ali Jinnah by L.K. Advani in Pakistan.

Advani had said, “His (Jinnah’s) address to the Constituent Assembly of Pakistan on August 11, 1947, is really a classic, a forceful espousal of a secular state in which, while every citizen would be free to practise his own religion, the state shall make no distinction between one citizen and another on grounds of faith.”

The RSS cracked down on Advani and later Jaswant Singh who wrote a book on Jinnah. This is their level of intolerance and Mukherjee wants us to believe he wanted to have a dialogue with the RSS.

Mukherjee probably rates his oratorical skills very highly. He may have thought he can reform, if not the Sangh leadership, the fresh graduates and make them give up their Hindu rashtra dreams. He is probably reassured by the successes he had while playing the role of mediator for the UPA. He had handled Anna Hazare so well his prodigy ended up becoming the CM; he neutralised Ramdev, who became a business tycoon, if not for Pranab the yoga guru could have become the UP CM for all you know.

Don’t let the Pranabda fan club in the media mislead you. Mukherjee didn’t go to the lion’s den and take the bull by its horns.

The speech in itself was mediocre. It could have been any of the speeches he made as President of India after Narendra Modi came to power. He just toned it down a bit, edited out references to gau raksha, lynchings, bigotry. In its place he copied a few lines from his other speeches about the 5,000 year old Indian civilisation, the sone ki chidiya that India was, the glory of Nalanda, all that are music to RSS ears. A Sangh spokesperson on TV channels said as much -- he said pretty much what we say. 

Mukherjee quoted Jawahar Lal Nehru from his book Discovery of India, but made only a passing reference to Gandhi. He said, “As Gandhiji explained Indian nationalism was not exclusive, nor aggressive, nor destructive.” Just one line on the Father of the Nation who spearheaded a freedom struggle that was boycotted by the RSS. Gandhi who lost his life to the ideology of RSS almost became a footnote in his speech, though it appeared in the middle somewhere.

The real news came a few hours before the speech. From the memorial of RSS founder K.B. Hedgewar. There Mukherjee noted in the visitors’ log, “Today I came here to pay my respect and homage to a great son of Mother India.” Anyone who reads it would think Hedgewar was some big hero who was denied his due by a repressionist regime for decades.

You could argue there is no need to read much into it. It was just an old man writing something about a dead man because he had to do write something. Journalists quoted ‘sources close to him’ as saying “What does one say of a dead man, especially who has been the Organising Committee Chairman of the AICC Session in 1920?”

Anything. He could have written anything. Mukherjee made a career out of writing convoluted, un-understandable resolutions with sentences so long, one would lose count and sight of the commas and semicolons. Anything Mukherjee writes, there is a method to it.

Arun Shourie very famously described the Modi govt as UPA + cow. Mukherjee’s speech was a bit like that -- RSS minus the bigotry.
So what was the purpose behind the speech?

The only good defence in Mukherjee’s favour I can think of is - he was bored, visited RSS headquarters for some sightseeing and went back after a guided tour.

In describing Hedgewar as a great son of Mother India, Mukherjee came off as an opportunist,  a backstabber and coward.

Tuesday, 5 June 2018

Praise the Modi or why archbishops need to shut up

Dear Filipe Neri Ferrao

Pardon my ignorance. This is the first time I am writing to an archbishop, I don’t know what is the proper way to address one. But the speed at which archbishops are issuing election advisories (again the wrong use of words), I have taken it upon myself to give you a few reasons why your club should keep quiet on politics.

1. Christians don’t count

In a country of 100 crore people, the 2.8 crore Christian population is like a drop in the ocean. You can influence elections in Kerala and the Northeast but not anywhere else.

2. Who cares for your criticism?

There was a time when a negative comment by an archbishop would embarrass the government of the day. Not anymore. Now it’s a badge of honour.

3. Why the trouble?

Why even take pains to issue such edicts. If your followers need to be told not to vote for Modi, then you might rather stay silent.

4. It’s a boomerang

Any comment by the Church on secularism, Constitution will be sold as as a Vatican conspiracy by the Sangh Parivar and the media through whatsapp and facebook. So much so we have started thinking secularism is a dirty word and a crime to boot.

5. Prayers don't count

If you truly believe weekly prayers are going to topple Narendra Modi, you must be the biggest believer in the world, bigger than even the Pope.

Hope you get the drift.

With best wishes

Jasoos Narayanan Kutty

Praise the Modi